Crowds of students and faculty members flooded Global Commons Monday evening as panelists emphasized that asylees and refugees from around the world have many similarities, but only one distinct difference.
Heather Scavone, director of the Humanitarian Immigration Law Clinic, was the first panelist to speak in the hot and overflowing room and argued that refugees and asylum seekers have similar benefits, challenges and grounds for protection under the law. She said the only difference between the two is refugees gain status before coming to America while individuals applying for asylum request status after entering the country.
“Around 17,000 refugees come to the United States a year from all around the world,” said panelist and Executive Director at North Carolina African Services Coalition, Million Mekonnen.
Because of extreme numbers of refugees immigrating to the United States, legal grounds must be in action for those fleeing to America. Scavone recited these five grounds as listed in the U.S. Obligation under domestic and international law:
1. Race
The individual is persecuted for linguistic groups, nationality, religious ethnicities or social descent.
2. Religion
The individual cannot actively practice their faith, social traditions or linguistic groups because of fear of harm.
3. Nationality
Wrongful treatment of people from the same place or people who are perceived to be from the same place.
4. Political Opinion
Interpreted stance of anti government by the regime in command or a dictatorship over one’s actions causing harm to the individual.
5. Membership in a social group
Persecution because of sexual identity, physical disability or membership in another social group deemed incorrect.
Heather Scavone, assistant professor of law and director of the Humanitarian Immigration Law Clinic, interacts with students and professors at the New Refugee and Immigrant Communities in Greensboro Panel Discussion at Elon University.
In order to gain approval into the United States, Scavone also emphasized the many benefits and challenges refugees and approved asylees face.
Challenges:
Family separation/reunification: Spouses and unmarried children under the age of 21 are automatically eligible for reunification, but the process can take years to finalize. Parents and minor siblings must be deemed a refugee under the requirements above to be eligible for reunification under a separate state program.
Scavone gave the example that if one spouse is persecuted for political beliefs but is married to a person with different beliefs who is not persecuted, this person would not be classified as a refugee and would not be reunified with their spouse.
Immigration Court: Refugees have no right to counsel in immigration court. If they cannot afford a lawyer, they are not automatically appointed one.
Benefits:
Benefits to refugees and asylees include U.S. citizenship, civic participation, eventual family reunification, permanent protection from deportation and preservation of important social benefits.